
Independent Revenues and Benefits Monday Discussion Group, 16 November 2026
Andy Mitchell’s weekly income changed by ten pence when he moved from income-related Employment and Support Allowance to Universal Credit. As I set out for the group, his Council Tax Reduction fell from 100% to 10%, and Somerset sent him a bill for £785.98 for the remainder of 2025/26. An hour later, we were debating whether six hours of paid work a week should count as a success. Those two questions belonged in the same discussion. Both were about what happens to people when they move from one system to another, and whether anyone has thought through what that move means for them.
The cliff edge Somerset should have seen coming
I asked Tom Clark whether he would sign off a scheme that produced the outcome in Somerset. “In one word, no,” he said. Similar schemes exist elsewhere, he pointed out, and an equality impact assessment ought to expose a cliff edge of that size before residents encounter it. In outlining the High Court case, I explained that Somerset had awarded full support to people on income-related ESA, while counting disability-related income differently under Universal Credit. The court quashed Mr Mitchell’s individual decision.
Gareth Morgan explained why redesigning a scheme around Universal Credit takes care. Legacy benefits were a fruit cocktail, where you could still pick out the individual pieces. Universal Credit is a smoothie. Once someone receives less than their maximum award, Gareth said, you cannot look at the payment and readily say how much of it is for disability, housing or caring. A council can write a rule about treating those elements separately. Working out how to apply it to the amount actually paid is another matter.
Paul Howarth thought Somerset had done too little to understand what managed migration would do to particular groups. He urged councils to compare like with like by modelling what would happen to the same household before and after the move. He also drew a distinction between banded schemes that count earnings and other income, and schemes that base their bands on earnings alone. The latter avoid this particular problem, he said, although where the bands are set still matters. For councils already consulting on next year’s scheme, the timing of the ruling made changes harder.
Nicki Duckworth thought some councils underestimated how much specialist work it takes to spot these outcomes. Penny Mitchell took the point into the council chamber. Her own council had identified that some larger families would lose support under a redesign, put that consequence explicitly before members and recorded their decision. A subsequent challenge was dropped. Her argument was that members should see the uncomfortable consequences while they still have a choice about the design. Sean O’Sullivan applied the same test to individual rules. Why is the band set there? Why is the deduction that amount? If you cannot explain a figure, he said, you should question why it is in the scheme.
The panel differed on what to do when modelling shows that some residents will lose out. Ian Savigar argued for contacting affected households early and considering transitional help where the loss would cause hardship. Robert Fox questioned the logic of using the Crisis and Resilience Fund to cushion losses the council had created through its own redesign. Tom had seen the practical case for cushioning at Enfield, where support for some households fell from 100% to 50%. He also said Liverpool and Wirral had been told by the Department for Work and Pensions that payments could go directly onto council tax accounts, with councils considering other household bills too. I came back to what a resident would have to do in practice. If they have to apply again for discretionary help, how many will get it in time?
Where are the jobs, and who will help people into them?
We discussed Alan Milburn’s review before the full report was available to us, so the debate drew on his broadcast interviews and what had been reported about the emerging proposals. I asked where the panel would spend the first extra pound, given the choice of earlier intervention in schools, better health support or more entry-level jobs.
Gareth Morgan chose jobs. An employment programme can help people into vacancies, he said, but it needs vacancies to work with. He was sceptical that another round of consultation would address the loss of training provision and the shift in apprenticeships away from some of the young people they were originally intended to reach.
Sean O’Sullivan feared the review would lead to benefit cuts for young disabled people. Reducing someone’s income would do nothing to improve their health, he argued, and employers and councils would need proper support if they were expected to help people with complex needs into work. I had heard Milburn’s interview differently. My reading was that he was talking about moving some spending towards practical support and that he had sought to reassure people with significant needs. I wanted to see where the published proposals would draw that line.
Paul Howarth thought the Government had invested too much political capital in the review for it to sit on a shelf. He wanted more substantial employment programmes and questioned whether local and strategic authorities might deliver some of that support better than the DWP does now. Tom Clark offered a place to start. Liverpool’s experience with young interns, including some with special educational needs and disabilities, had persuaded him that councils could build clearer routes from school into local government. That could give young people a first foothold and help services that are struggling to recruit and relying heavily on agency staff.
Robert Fox backed the idea and asked who would train and supervise new recruits in a hybrid workplace. He suggested councils could recruit and train together, pooling the staff and time needed to give apprentices a decent start. He also pointed to Enterprise Works, which gives adults with learning difficulties experience making products such as sheds, fences and planters. It showed what a council could provide, he said, and how difficult it was to sustain without proper funding. Sean saw the same problem with councils working separately elsewhere. He described authorities paying software suppliers to write essentially the same audit query because nobody had shared the work already done.
Would six hours a week count?
I brought in Denmark’s Fleksjob scheme as a comparison. Under the model we discussed, municipalities assess people with substantial and lasting limits on their capacity to work. Employers pay for the work the person can do, and public support supplements their earnings. The evidence I presented pointed to better access to paid work, often for a small number of hours. It gave much less reason to expect savings on benefits.
Ian Savigar was unconvinced that six hours a week amounted to success on its own. He could see value if it gave someone a route to more hours, but wanted to know what useful work and support could fit into such a short week. Gareth Morgan cared more about the result for the person than the label attached to the payment. Paul Howarth urged us to look at the whole Danish system before assuming a single part would work here. How municipalities are funded, what other support people can draw on and how social security is organised all affect what the scheme can achieve.
Ian’s question about six hours stayed with me. For someone who wants to work and can manage six hours, that may be a real gain. Whether it lasts will depend on the job, the support and what happens to their income when they take it. That brings us back to Somerset. Before asking someone to make a change, we ought to be able to show them what it will mean for their household, right down to the council tax bill.
The Recording can be found here
Downloads
Please note that the handout contains additional slides covering other items of interest in the news and job adverts, which are provided in partnership with Business Smart Solutions (https://www.businesssmartsolutions.co.uk/).