
We at Visionary Network welcome Alan Milburn’s call for radical change. Nearly a million young people are outside education, employment or training, and we have spent years launching schemes to help them. Some of those schemes worked. The harder question is why we keep having to start again. Milburn’s most ambitious idea is to make access to a credible opportunity, and the support needed to take it up, a permanent responsibility of government. A six-month job can be a good start. A system that is still there for you when the six months are up would be a bigger change.
We have tried paid jobs before, with some success
The New Deal for Young People combined job-search support with measures including wage subsidies. Researchers estimated that it increased moves into employment by about five percentage points, with some evidence that the effect was smaller over the longer term. The Future Jobs Fund offered six months of paid work. The Department for Work and Pensions estimated that participants were 11 percentage points more likely to be in unsubsidised employment after two years than they would otherwise have been. Its evaluation also estimated a net cost to the Exchequer alongside a net benefit to society. That is a distinction worth remembering when the Treasury asks whether a programme pays for itself.
Kickstart brought the six-month subsidised job back during the pandemic. The DWP estimated that, for every 100 participants, 11 more were in employment two years after starting than among comparable young people who did not take part. The two estimates of 11 percentage points come from different programmes, cohorts and evaluations. Both give us a reason to take paid placements seriously and to judge them by what happens after the subsidy ends.
So, there is an element of rehashing, and some of it is worth keeping. Bringing forward access to the existing Jobs Guarantee from 18 to 12 months from spring 2027, as Pat McFadden confirmed, is a useful step. The broader Milburn test is whether a young person can get help before they have spent a year out of work, including those who never come through the Jobcentre door.
Denmark shows what it takes to make a job fit the person
Denmark’s Fleksjob scheme is particularly relevant to Milburn’s proposals for disabled young people. Introduced in 1998 and reformed in 2013, it provides subsidised employment for people with substantially and permanently reduced work capacity. The employer pays for the work the person can do and the public subsidy supplements their income. A job can start at only a few hours a week. That gives an employer a practical way to offer paid work to someone who could make a contribution but cannot sustain a conventional working week. Fleksjob applies beyond the under-25s, so its results tell us most about supported employment for people with reduced work capacity. GOV.UK
Has it worked? On one important measure, yes. Evidence reviewed for the Nordic Council of Ministers found that the 2013 reform brought more people into jobs of up to ten hours a week. The OECD also reported early signs of fewer people waiting for a placement and a higher share of jobs in private firms. The earlier scheme had shown how costs could mount when existing jobs were converted to subsidised ones and people had few routes out of the scheme. For us, the lesson is to design jobs around what people can sustainably do, check whether the subsidy is creating opportunities that would otherwise be unavailable, and value stable paid work even where someone never progresses to longer hours.
The radical part is making the guarantee real
McFadden backed a statutory Opportunity and Support Guarantee and locally delivered, personalised support. Milburn’s proposed Youth Allowance and changes to disability benefits are still for government to consider. That leaves a choice for the White Paper. If local leaders are to be held accountable, they will need the funding and authority to bring employers, colleges, health services and councils together, with enough real jobs, apprenticeships and training places to make good on the guarantee. A named adviser is valuable when they can get something done.
We would put one principle up front. The state must deliver its side of the guarantee before it penalises a young person for failing to engage. Has the young person been offered somewhere they can get to, with hours they can manage and support they can actually access? If the offer is a job, can the household afford the transition? Those are practical questions about transport, health, housing and money. They deserve an answer before anyone’s income is put at risk.
That is where councils have something specific to contribute. The 2021 Census found that just over half of 20- to 24-year-olds in England and Wales lived with their parents. That is a figure for the whole age group, but it gives councils a good reason to start with the family-home scenario. When a young person takes a job, a parent’s Council Tax Reduction or Housing Benefit can change under the applicable rules. For a young person renting independently, the pressure may come when the placement ends and the wages stop. A better-off check should cover the household where relevant, and it should look at both ends of the placement.
Our view at Visionary Network is that Milburn has made the case for a lasting local service built around a national guarantee. We would keep the paid jobs that past evaluations give us reason to back, borrow from Denmark where work needs to be shaped around someone’s capacity, and judge the reforms by whether young people are still earning or learning a year later. The White Paper will tell us how far ministers are prepared to go. The first things we’ll look for are who has the duty to act, who pays for the support, and what a young person can expect when the first offer falls through.